poplitealqueen:
morgynleri:
Clone Wars, only because I got further before I noped out, and noped out because of boredom not uneasiness and frustration.
For this meme.
(Remind me to pick your brain about SWR sometime. TCW too. May be weird, but I love knowing why people stop liking things.)
First, disclaimer:
Everything that follows under the cut is my opinion, it might not fit with anyone else’s take away from TCW (primarily) or Rebels. Don’t try to convince me to give either show another chance, I don’t have the energy to deal with the frustration and rage on the off-chance there might be good stuff in there.
Also, anyone who decides to yell at me that my Opinions Are Wrong will be blocked, and not engaged with. Polite attempts to enlighten me about something I might have missed due to noping out will not be responded to tonight, as I am a cranky bear and want to go back to my rewatch and yelling at DS9 episodes.
Grumpy. Sith. Murder Kitten.
Not evil wanna-be Obi-Wan with an inferiority complex and no fucking reason to be alive. I mean, he lost half his spine, his digestive system, and quite possibly his diaphragm at the end of That Fucking Scene. If he got immediate medical attention for the trauma, maybe he could have lived for a little while. But that level of trauma, with no medical attention? Nope. I do not believe it.
I love Maul, grumpy Sith murder-kitten of TPM. I think he’s adorable, and fills his role admirably. I like writing AUs where he survives Naboo, for one reason or another. I’m also content to make him very dead, if the narrative calls for it. Because he had a Good Death – one that made sense for his character arc (what little there was of it), that was cathartic and emotionally satisfying, and was useful and good for the narrative.
Filoni decided that Maul didn’t deserve a Good Death, and he took that away from him. He didn’t even have the decency to do it in a way that might have made sense, either. He decided that Maul clearly survived a trauma he should not have been able to, in conditions that were a ripe breeding ground for infection and disease and further trauma, while neglecting to show how he could have done so while missing vital organs and part of his central nervous system.
Of course there are fan theories to explain the gaping plot hole that Filoni blithely created where there had not been one, but that doesn’t excuse Filoni’s mess.
I still love Rex and Cody and Ahsoka and Wolffe, and the various other clones that we get from TCW. I like that we get to see minor characters explored more.
I will gladly keep Hera and her crew from Rebels, and play with them when I’m working with that era. I’m glad to know that Numa shows up there.
But Filoni can take his fanfic and take a long walk out an airlock. I do not fucking care that it’s canon. It’s boring. War is boring. The reasons behind it can be fascinating, but there’s so damned little of the intricacies behind things and so much focus on what battle is happening now. And look at all the awesome men who are fighting this war, the ideal soldiers.
It has it’s good points, it does. And I like prying the shiny awesome out of the rest. But it bores me, and Maul’s being cheated of his death and just not allowed to die pisses me off. (Which, granted, I didn’t actually find out about until after I noped out because bored now.)
What made me uneasy and frustrated with Rebels wasn’t so much what I watched as the spoilers for the second half of season two. I didn’t have words at the time to go “this is what makes me not want to watch it”, but everything I heard and saw of it (and not everyone on my dashboard disliked it, some of them genuinely do enjoy it) just. Made me twitchy. And then there was the stuff about Maul, and twitchy became cranky bitching in the privacy of my head. Honestly, I’m not even sure I have the words now to say why it made me twitchy even before I heard about Maul coming back.
*sighs*
And this is with my usual attitude toward canon being “someone gave me shiny toys to play with!”